Lumen

Doubt

2008 ยท John Patrick Shanley ยท Drama

Caution. Age: 18+. A Catholic review of this movie for parents.

Our review

A strict nun thinks a kind priest has hurt a boy at their school. She has no proof, only a strong feeling. She pushes until the priest leaves, and then she cries that she has doubts. It is a serious film about certainty and suspicion, and it is for adults. The one age is 18, set by the Catholic A-III classification (USCCB); Common Sense Media says 17+ and the MPAA says PG-13.

For parents

One age: 18, set by the Catholic A-III classification (USCCB). Common Sense Media says 17+; the MPAA rating is PG-13. The whole story rests on an unproven suspicion of a priest abusing a boy; per Wikipedia the film never confirms it. Common Sense lists a heated argument, a mother describing a father's beatings, a boy suspected of drinking wine, smoking and a single curse. A mother says her son is gay; the plot uses it to explain her fear for him. Talk about it: Is a strong feeling enough to ruin a man? Aloysius lies to get her result. What does the Church teach about rash judgment and about protecting children? Is doubt the same as faith?

See all Lumen reviews

For You

Lumen is free. No ads, nothing to buy.

Tell us what you'd change