The Messenger: The Story of Joan of Arc

1999 ยท Historical Drama

Avoid. A Catholic review of this movie for parents.

Our review

A deconstruction built to unmake a canonized saint. The saints Joan actually testified to never appear; in their place, Christ shows up only as a bleeding, screaming, accusatory apparition, and the loving Christ is wholly absent. Her sanctity is rewritten as trauma, vengeance, and possible madness, with invented sacrilege along the way. Lumen rates its doctrinal fidelity 0 out of 5.

For parents

Skip it entirely. If someone's already seen it: the real Joan's trial transcript survives, and her recorded answers are more astonishing than anything Besson invented. For a worthy Joan film, Dreyer's The Passion of Joan of Arc (1928) is built from that transcript.

See all Lumen reviews

Tell us what you'd change

Save with your email

We send a link. No password. Tap it and your list is saved.